书城两性关系同性恋与法
8157700000035

第35章 附录(20)

Although,onceagain,intheU.S.publicpoliciesarefractiousandcontradictory,lesbianandgayparentsaremorevisibleandorganizedtherethanelsewhere.EstimatesplacethenumberoflesbianandgayparentsintheU.S.betweentwotoeightmillion,andthe2000Censusrecordedthatthehouseholdsof34percentoffemalesame-sexcouplesand22percentofmalesame-sexcouplesincludeddependentchildren.Lesbianandgayparentsandtheirchildrenparticipateinnumeroussupportgroups,organizations,specialcampsandvacations,andsympatheticimagesandstoriesaboutthemappearfrequentlyinthepopularmedia.Gayparentshavealsomadegreatstridesinsecuringlegalrightsinmanystates,althoughasignificantbacklashisworkingtooverturnthesewhereitcan.Onestate(Florida)bansgayandlesbianadoptionexplicitly,severalothersdosoindirectly,andopponentsofgayparenthoodhaveintroducedproposalsforsuchbansinseveralotherstates.However,amajorityofthefiftystatesallowsingle-parentadoptionsirrespectiveofsexualorientation,six(includingthemostpopulous)expresslyallowsame-sexcouplestoadoptchildrenjointly,andmanyoftherestgrantsuchadoptionslocally.Perhapsunsurprisingly,theU.S.representsthevanguardingayaccesstocommercialARTservicesincludingspermbanks,eggdonors,andpaidsurrogates.LesbianshelpedtoorganizeandoperateseveralspermbanksintheU.S.,andLosAngelesishometoGrowingGenerations,theworld’sfirstsurrogacyagencyfoundedprimarilybyandforgaymen,whichservesaglobalclienteleofaffluentgaymenwhodesirebiologicaloffspring.

ParadoxesandPotentialofLesbianandGayFamilyGoals

Lookingbackwardoverthesedazzlinginternationalshiftsinsexualityandfamilyforms,lesbianandgaycampaignsformarriageandparentingrightscanseemasparadoxicalastheywereunpredictable.First,gaysandlesbiansbegantostrivefortherighttomarryattheveryhistoricalmomentwhenheterosexualmarriageevincedmanysymptomsofinstitutionaldecline.Heterosexualcouplesinmostadvancedindustrialsocietiesnowcohabitoutsidemarriagemorefrequently,marrylater,ifatall,divorcemoreoften,andspendagreaterportionoftheiradultlivesunmarriedthantheydidunderthemodernfamilyregime.Whereoncefreechoicemarriagemeantbeingfreetochoosewhoyouwouldmarry,nowitmeansbeingobligedtochooseif,when,how,forhowlong,andhowmanytimestomarryaswell.

Thedeclineofnearlyuniversalandlife-longmarriagesamongpresumptivelyheterosexualcouplesraisessignificantpolicyquestionsaboutwhetherandhowtorecognizeotherformsofintimateadultrelationships.Shoulddomesticpartnershipsbeavailabletoheterosexualaswellashomosexualcouples?Mustsexualunionsbethebasisfordomesticbenefits,responsibilities,andrights,orshouldthesebeextendedtootherformsofcommittedrelationships?Wouldlegalizingsame-sexmarriageunderminefamilyandsexualdiversityandfurtherdiscriminateagainstsingleadultsandtheirdependents?Advocatesandopponentsofsame-sexmarriagealikeholdvaryingviewsonwhetherallowingsame-sexcouplestowedwilldomoretostrengthenortoweakenmarriageasaninstitution.Inthisregard,itisstrikingthatheterosexualmarriagerateswerealreadycomparativelylowinthefirstnationsthatopenedtheinstitutiontosame-sexcouples,marriageconfersfewmaterialbenefitsinthesesocieties,andtheydonotdiscriminatesignificantlyagainstunmarriedcouples.Inotherwords,forthemostpartithasbeeneasierforsame-sexcouplestoachieveequalaccesstomarriagewheremarriagebearscomparativelylittlesocial,moral,andeconomicweight.