"Permit yourself, doctor," he said. "This argument of Cocoleu's imbecility is one which you have pleaded from the beginning, and which appeared to you, you said, so conclusive, that there was no need of looking for any other."Before the doctor could find an answer, M. Folgat went on,--"Let it be, on the contrary, established that Cocoleu really knows what he says, and all is changed. The prosecution is justified, by an opinion of the faculty, in saying to M. de Boiscoran, 'You need not deny any longer. You have been seen; here is a witness.' "These arguments must have struck Dr. Seignebos very forcibly; for he remained silent for at least ten long seconds, wiping his gold spectacles with a pensive air. Had he really done harm to Jacques de Boiscoran, while he meant to help him? But he was not the man to be long in doubt. He replied in a dry tone,--"I will not discuss that, gentlemen. I will ask you, only one question: 'Yes or no, do you believe in M. de Boiscoran's innocence?' ""We believe in it fully," replied the two men.
"Then, gentlemen, it seems to me we are running no risk in trying to unmask an impostor."That was not the young lawyer's opinion.
"To prove that Cocoleu knows what he says," he replied, "would be fatal, unless we can prove at the same time that he has told a falsehood, and that his evidence has been prompted by others. Can we prove that? Have we any means to prove that his obstinacy in not replying to any questions arises from his fear that his answers might convict him of perjury?"The doctor would hear nothing more. He said rather uncourteously,--"Lawyer's quibbles! I know only one thing; and that is truth.""It will not always do to tell it," murmured the lawyer.
"Yes, sir, always," replied the physician,--"always, and at all hazards, and whatever may happen. I am M. de Boiscoran's friend; but Iam still more the friend of truth. If Cocoleu is a wretched impostor, as I am firmly convinced, our duty is to unmask him."Dr. Seignebos did not say--and he probably did not confess it to himself--that it was a personal matter between Cocoleu and himself. He thought Cocoleu had taken him in, and been the cause of a host of small witticisms, under which he had suffered cruelly, though he had allowed no one to see it. To unmask Cocoleu would have given him his revenge, and return upon his enemies the ridicule with which they had overwhelmed him.
"I have made up my mind," he said, "and, whatever you may resolve, Imean to go to work at once, and try to obtain the appointment of a commission.""It might be prudent," M. Folgat said, "to consider before doing any thing, to consult with M. Magloire.""I do not want to consult with Magloire when duty calls.""You will grant us twenty-four hours, I hope."Dr. Seignebos frowned till he looked formidable.
"Not an hour," he replied; "and I go from here to M. Daubigeon, the commonwealth attorney."Thereupon, taking his hat and cane, he bowed and left, as dissatisfied as possible, without stopping even to answer M. de Chandore, who asked him how Count Claudieuse was, who was, according to reports in town, getting worse and worse.
"Hang the old original!" cried M. de Chandore before the doctor had left the passage.
Then turning to M. Folgat, he added,--
"I must, however, confess that you received the great news which he brought rather coldly.""The very fact of the news being so very grave," replied the advocate, "made me wish for time to consider. If Cocoleu pretends to be imbecile, or, at least, exaggerates his incapacity, then we have a confirmation of what M. de Boiscoran last night told Miss Dionysia. It would be the proof of an odious trap of a long-premeditated vengeance.
Here is the turning-point of the affair evidently."M. de Chandore was bitterly undeceived.
"What!" he said, "you think so, and you refuse to support Dr.
Seignebos, who is certainly an honest man?"The young lawyer shook his head.
"I wanted to have twenty-four hours' delay, because we must absolutely consult M. de Boiscoran. Could I tell the doctor so? Had I a right to take him into Miss Dionysia's secret?""You are right," murmured M. de Chandore, "you are right."But, in order to write to M. de Boiscoran, Dionysia's assistance was necessary; and she did not reappear till the afternoon, looking very pale, but evidently armed with new courage.
M. Folgat dictated to her certain questions to ask the prisoner.
She hastened to write them in cipher; and about four o'clock the letter was sent to Mechinet, the clerk.
The next evening the answer came.
"Dr. Seignebos is no doubt right, my dear friends," wrote Jacques.
"I have but too good reasons to be sure that Cocoleu's imbecility is partly assumed, and that his evidence has been prompted by others. Still I must beg you will take no steps that would lead to another medical investigation. The slightest imprudence may ruin me. For Heaven's sake wait till the end of the preliminary investigation, which is now near at hand, from what M. Galpin tells me."The letter was read in the family circle; and the poor mother uttered a cry of despair as she heard those words of resignation.
"Are we going to obey him," she said, "when we all know that he is ruining himself by his obstinacy?"Dionysia rose, and said,--
"Jacques alone can judge his situation, and he alone, therefore, has the right to command. Our duty is to obey. I appeal to M. Folgat."The young advocate nodded his head.
"Every thing has been done that could be done," he said. "Now we can only wait."